Sleepfare

Faraway Sag Harbor

★★★★ 31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor, US

8.9 guest rating· 251 reviews

About this hotel

Luxurious Accommodations

Baron's Cove in Sag Harbor offers elegantly furnished guest rooms equipped with modern amenities, including flat-screen TVs and luxurious bathrobes. Select rooms even provide stunning views of the sea or garden, ensuring a memorable stay.

Gourmet Dining Experience

Indulge in a culinary journey at the on-site restaurant, where you can savor fresh American cuisine for lunch and dinner daily. Treat yourself to a delightful breakfast and brunch on the weekends, promising a delectable start to your day.

Leisure and Activities

From relaxing by the seasonal saltwater swimming pool to exploring the picturesque surroundings on a bike hired from the hotel, Baron's Cove provides ample opportunities for leisure and recreation. The 24-hour front desk is always ready to assist, ensuring a seamless and enjoyable stay.

Book your stay at Baron's Cove in Sag Harbor today for a luxurious and unforgettable experience.

Rooms & rates

Pick your dates. Prices are live, not cached.

Village Two Double Room

Sleeps 4 · 2× Double bed

  • Air conditioning
  • Bathrobe
  • Private bathroom
  • Free WiFi
  • Safety deposit box

<p><strong>2 Double Beds</strong></p><p>Soundproofed room</p><br/><p><b>Relax</b> - In-room massage available</p><p><b>Internet</b> - Free WiFi 100+ Mbps (good for 1–2 people or up to 6 devices) </p><p><b>Entertainment</b> - 48-inch flat-screen TV with premium channels, streaming services, iPod dock</p><p><b>Food & Drink</b> - Espresso maker, room service (limited hours), and free bottled water</p><p><b>Sleep</b> - Tempur-Pedic bed, Egyptian cotton linens, a down duvet, blackout drapes/curtains, and turndown service </p><p><b>Bathroom</b> - Private bathroom, bathtub or shower, bathrobes, and designer toiletries</p><p><b>Practical</b> - Safe, phone, and wet bar</p><p><b>Comfort</b> - Air conditioning, daily housekeeping, and heating</p><p><b>Accessibility</b> - Visual fire alarm</p><p><b>Need to Know</b> - No cribs (infant beds) or rollaway/extra beds available</p><p>Non-Smoking</p><p>Room is accessed via exterior corridors </p>

Deluxe Room, 2 Queen Beds, Pool Access, Bay View

Sleeps 4 · 2× Queen Bed

  • Air conditioning
  • Bathrobe
  • Private bathroom
  • Free WiFi
  • Safety deposit box

<p><strong>2 Queen Beds</strong></p><p>Overlooking the bay</p><br/><p><b>Relax</b> - In-room massage available</p><p><b>Internet</b> - Free WiFi 100+ Mbps (good for 1–2 people or up to 6 devices) </p><p><b>Entertainment</b> - 48-inch flat-screen TV with premium channels, streaming services, iPod dock</p><p><b>Food & Drink</b> - Espresso maker, room service (limited hours), and free bottled water</p><p><b>Sleep</b> - Tempur-Pedic bed, Egyptian cotton linens, a down duvet, blackout drapes/curtains, and turndown service </p><p><b>Bathroom</b> - Private bathroom, bathtub or shower, bathrobes, and designer toiletries</p><p><b>Practical</b> - Safe, phone, and wet bar</p><p><b>Comfort</b> - Air conditioning, daily housekeeping, and heating</p><p><b>Accessibility</b> - Visual fire alarm</p><p><b>Need to Know</b> - No cribs (infant beds) or rollaway/extra beds available</p><p>Non-Smoking</p><p>Room is accessed via exterior corridors </p>

Superior Room, 1 King Bed with Sofa bed, Harbor View

Sleeps 3 · 48 m² · King bed, Sofa bed

  • Air conditioning
  • Bathrobe
  • Private bathroom
  • Free WiFi
  • Safety deposit box

<p><strong>1 King Bed and 1 Double Sofa Bed</strong></p><p>520-sq-foot room with harbor views </p><br/><p><b>Relax</b> - In-room massage available</p><p><b>Internet</b> - Free WiFi 100+ Mbps (good for 1–2 people or up to 6 devices) </p><p><b>Entertainment</b> - 48-inch flat-screen TV with premium channels, streaming services, iPod dock</p><p><b>Food & Drink</b> - Espresso maker, room service (limited hours), and free bottled water</p><p><b>Sleep</b> - Tempur-Pedic bed, Egyptian cotton linens, a down duvet, blackout drapes/curtains, and turndown service </p><p><b>Bathroom</b> - Private bathroom, bathtub or shower, bathrobes, and designer toiletries</p><p><b>Practical</b> - Safe, phone, and wet bar</p><p><b>Comfort</b> - Air conditioning, daily housekeeping, and heating</p><p><b>Accessibility</b> - Visual fire alarm</p><p><b>Need to Know</b> - No cribs (infant beds) or rollaway/extra beds available</p><p>Non-Smoking</p><p>Room is accessed via exterior corridors </p>

Deluxe Room, 2 Double Beds

Sleeps 4 · 26 m² · 2× Double bed

  • Air conditioning
  • Bathrobe
  • Private bathroom
  • Free WiFi
  • Safety deposit box

<p><strong>2 Double Beds</strong></p><p>285 sq feet </p><br/><p><b>Relax</b> - In-room massage available</p><p><b>Internet</b> - Free WiFi 100+ Mbps (good for 1–2 people or up to 6 devices) </p><p><b>Entertainment</b> - 48-inch flat-screen TV with premium channels, streaming services, iPod dock</p><p><b>Food & Drink</b> - Espresso maker, room service (limited hours), and free bottled water</p><p><b>Sleep</b> - Tempur-Pedic bed, Egyptian cotton linens, a down duvet, blackout drapes/curtains, and turndown service </p><p><b>Bathroom</b> - Private bathroom, bathtub or shower, bathrobes, and designer toiletries</p><p><b>Practical</b> - Safe, phone, and wet bar</p><p><b>Comfort</b> - Air conditioning, daily housekeeping, and heating</p><p><b>Accessibility</b> - Visual fire alarm</p><p><b>Need to Know</b> - No cribs (infant beds) or rollaway/extra beds available</p><p>Non-Smoking</p><p>Room is accessed via exterior corridors </p>

Suite, 1 King Bed, Harbor View

Sleeps 2 · 41 m² · King bed

  • Air conditioning
  • Bathrobe
  • Private bathroom
  • Free WiFi
  • Safety deposit box

<p><strong>1 King Bed</strong></p><p>450-sq-foot room with harbor views </p><br/><p><b>Relax</b> - In-room massage available</p><p><b>Internet</b> - Free WiFi 100+ Mbps (good for 1–2 people or up to 6 devices) </p><p><b>Entertainment</b> - 48-inch flat-screen TV with premium channels, streaming services, iPod dock</p><p><b>Food & Drink</b> - Espresso maker, room service (limited hours), and free bottled water</p><p><b>Sleep</b> - Tempur-Pedic bed, Egyptian cotton linens, a down duvet, blackout drapes/curtains, and turndown service </p><p><b>Bathroom</b> - Private bathroom, bathtub or shower, bathrobes, and designer toiletries</p><p><b>Practical</b> - Safe, phone, and wet bar</p><p><b>Comfort</b> - Air conditioning, daily housekeeping, and heating</p><p><b>Accessibility</b> - Visual fire alarm</p><p><b>Need to Know</b> - No cribs (infant beds) or rollaway/extra beds available</p><p>Non-Smoking</p><p>Room is accessed via exterior corridors </p>

Superior Loft, 1 King Bed, Harbor View

Sleeps 2 · 48 m² · King bed

  • Air conditioning
  • Bathrobe
  • Private bathroom
  • Free WiFi
  • Safety deposit box

<p><strong>1 King Bed</strong></p><p>520-sq-foot room with harbor views </p><br/><p><b>Relax</b> - In-room massage available</p><p><b>Internet</b> - Free WiFi 100+ Mbps (good for 1–2 people or up to 6 devices) </p><p><b>Entertainment</b> - 48-inch flat-screen TV with premium channels, streaming services, iPod dock</p><p><b>Food & Drink</b> - Espresso maker, room service (limited hours), and free bottled water</p><p><b>Sleep</b> - Tempur-Pedic bed, Egyptian cotton linens, a down duvet, blackout drapes/curtains, and turndown service </p><p><b>Bathroom</b> - Private bathroom, bathtub or shower, bathrobes, and designer toiletries</p><p><b>Practical</b> - Safe, phone, and wet bar</p><p><b>Comfort</b> - Air conditioning, daily housekeeping, and heating</p><p><b>Accessibility</b> - Visual fire alarm</p><p><b>Need to Know</b> - No cribs (infant beds) or rollaway/extra beds available</p><p>Non-Smoking</p><p>Room is accessed via exterior corridors </p>

Deluxe Room, 1 King Bed with Sofa bed, Pool Access, Harbor View

Sleeps 4 · 32 m² · King bed, Sofa bed

  • Air conditioning
  • Bathrobe
  • Private bathroom
  • Free WiFi
  • Safety deposit box

<p><strong>1 King Bed and 1 Double Sofa Bed</strong></p><p>350-sq-foot room with bay views </p><br/><p><b>Relax</b> - In-room massage available</p><p><b>Internet</b> - Free WiFi 100+ Mbps (good for 1–2 people or up to 6 devices) </p><p><b>Entertainment</b> - 48-inch flat-screen TV with premium channels, streaming services, iPod dock</p><p><b>Food & Drink</b> - Espresso maker, room service (limited hours), and free bottled water</p><p><b>Sleep</b> - Tempur-Pedic bed, Egyptian cotton linens, a down duvet, blackout drapes/curtains, and turndown service </p><p><b>Bathroom</b> - Private bathroom, bathtub or shower, bathrobes, and designer toiletries</p><p><b>Practical</b> - Safe, phone, and wet bar</p><p><b>Comfort</b> - Air conditioning, daily housekeeping, and heating</p><p><b>Accessibility</b> - Visual fire alarm</p><p><b>Need to Know</b> - No cribs (infant beds) or rollaway/extra beds available</p><p>Non-Smoking</p><p>Room is accessed via exterior corridors </p>

Suite, Multiple Beds, Balcony (The Barons Suite - Water View)

Sleeps 7 · 60 m² · 2× King bed, Sofa bed

  • Air conditioning
  • Bathrobe
  • Private bathroom
  • Free WiFi
  • Safety deposit box

<p><strong>2 King Beds and 1 Double Sofa Bed</strong></p><p>650 sq feet </p><br/><p><b>Relax</b> - In-room massage available</p><p><b>Internet</b> - Free WiFi 100+ Mbps (good for 1–2 people or up to 6 devices) </p><p><b>Entertainment</b> - 48-inch flat-screen TV with premium channels, streaming services, iPod dock</p><p><b>Food & Drink</b> - Espresso maker, room service (limited hours), and free bottled water</p><p><b>Sleep</b> - Tempur-Pedic bed, Egyptian cotton linens, a down duvet, blackout drapes/curtains, and turndown service </p><p><b>Bathroom</b> - Private bathroom, bathtub or shower, bathrobes, and designer toiletries</p><p><b>Practical</b> - Safe, phone, and wet bar; rollaway beds (free) available on request</p><p><b>Comfort</b> - Air conditioning, daily housekeeping, and heating</p><p><b>Accessibility</b> - Visual fire alarm</p><p><b>Need to Know</b> - No cribs (infant beds) available</p><p>Non-Smoking</p><p>Room is accessed via exterior corridors </p>

Superior Room, 2 Queen Beds, Harbor View

Sleeps 4 · 32 m² · 2× Queen Bed

  • Air conditioning
  • Bathrobe
  • Private bathroom
  • Free WiFi
  • Safety deposit box

<p><strong>2 Queen Beds</strong></p><p>350-sq-foot room with harbor views </p><br/><p><b>Relax</b> - In-room massage available</p><p><b>Internet</b> - Free WiFi 100+ Mbps (good for 1–2 people or up to 6 devices) </p><p><b>Entertainment</b> - 48-inch flat-screen TV with premium channels, streaming services, iPod dock</p><p><b>Food & Drink</b> - Espresso maker, room service (limited hours), and free bottled water</p><p><b>Sleep</b> - Tempur-Pedic bed, Egyptian cotton linens, a down duvet, blackout drapes/curtains, and turndown service </p><p><b>Bathroom</b> - Private bathroom, bathtub or shower, bathrobes, and designer toiletries</p><p><b>Practical</b> - Safe, phone, and wet bar</p><p><b>Comfort</b> - Air conditioning, daily housekeeping, and heating</p><p><b>Accessibility</b> - Visual fire alarm</p><p><b>Need to Know</b> - No cribs (infant beds) or rollaway/extra beds available</p><p>Non-Smoking</p><p>Room is accessed via exterior corridors </p>

Deluxe Room, 1 King Bed

Sleeps 2 · 26 m² · King bed

  • Air conditioning
  • Bathrobe
  • Private bathroom
  • Free WiFi
  • Safety deposit box

<p><strong>1 King Bed</strong></p><p>285 sq feet </p><br/><p><b>Relax</b> - In-room massage available</p><p><b>Internet</b> - Free WiFi 100+ Mbps (good for 1–2 people or up to 6 devices) </p><p><b>Entertainment</b> - 48-inch flat-screen TV with premium channels, streaming services, iPod dock</p><p><b>Food & Drink</b> - Espresso maker, room service (limited hours), and free bottled water</p><p><b>Sleep</b> - Tempur-Pedic bed, Egyptian cotton linens, a down duvet, blackout drapes/curtains, and turndown service </p><p><b>Bathroom</b> - Private bathroom, bathtub or shower, bathrobes, and designer toiletries</p><p><b>Practical</b> - Safe, phone, and wet bar</p><p><b>Comfort</b> - Air conditioning, daily housekeeping, and heating</p><p><b>Accessibility</b> - Visual fire alarm</p><p><b>Need to Know</b> - No cribs (infant beds) or rollaway/extra beds available</p><p>Non-Smoking</p><p>Room is accessed via exterior corridors </p>

Amenities

  • WiFi available
  • Outdoor pool
  • Outdoor pool - seasonal
  • Swimming pool
  • Spa/wellness center
  • Fitness center
  • Fitness classes
  • Fitness facilities
  • Free Parking
  • Accessible parking
  • Private parking
  • Street parking
  • Valet parking
  • Breakfast in the room
Show all 88 amenities
  • Restaurant
  • Bar
  • Snack bar
  • Air conditioning
  • Pet bowls
  • Beach
  • 24-hour front desk
  • Tour desk
  • Business center
  • Room service
  • 24-hour security
  • Non-smoking throughout
  • Family rooms
  • Aerobics
  • Allergy-free room
  • ATM/cash machine on site
  • Babysitting/child services
  • Bike tours
  • Board games/puzzles
  • Canoeing
  • CCTV in common areas
  • CCTV outside property
  • Coffee Shop on site
  • Concierge service
  • Cycling
  • Daily housekeeping
  • Designated smoking area
  • Dry cleaning
  • Electric vehicle charging station
  • Entertainment staff
  • Evening entertainment
  • Express check-in/check-out
  • Facilities for disabled guests
  • Fax/photocopying
  • Fire extinguishers
  • Fishing
  • Fruits
  • Games room
  • Garden
  • Hand sanitizer in guest room and key areas
  • Happy hour
  • Heating
  • Ironing service
  • Key access
  • Key card access
  • Kid meals
  • Laundry
  • Lift / Elevator
  • Live music/performance
  • Luggage storage
  • Massage services
  • Meeting/banquet facilities
  • Outdoor fireplace
  • Outdoor furniture
  • Packed lunches
  • Private check-in/check-out
  • Safety deposit box
  • Security alarm
  • Shared lounge/TV area
  • Shared stationery like menus, pens are removed
  • Shuttle service
  • Shuttle service (free)
  • Smoke alarms
  • Soundproof rooms
  • Special diet menus - on request
  • Staff adhere to local safety protocols
  • Sun terrace
  • Sun umbrellas
  • Tennis court
  • Tennis equipment
  • Terrace
  • Water sport facilities on site
  • Wine/champagne
  • Yoga classes

Location

© OpenStreetMap contributors

31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor, US

Check-in
from 04:00 PM to 12:00 AM
Check-out
until 12:00 PM

What guests say8.9251 reviews

+ Great location+ Friendly staff+ Comfortable amenities+ Good food and beverage options− Musty smells in rooms− Some staffing issues reported− Limited food availability at times
Cleanliness8.0
Service9.4
Location9.5
Room Quality8.4
Amenities9.5
Value for Money8.4

Guest review

1.0

− I rarely write negative reviews, but I feel compelled to warn other travelers. This hotel is a classic example of “a pig with lipstick on.” While it has been remodeled, it still feels like an old motel underneath, and despite the renovations, they simply haven’t been able to shake that motel atmosphere. The appearance has been updated, but the overall experience certainly hasn’t. The photos on the hotel’s website do not accurately represent the experience or the feeling of staying here. They create the impression of a luxurious boutique property, but the reality is quite different. We paid an average of over $1,300 per night for the most basic, small room with a tiny bathroom, a rate that included approximately $350 per night in resort fees and taxes. At that price point, we expected an exceptional experience. Instead, we felt the hotel delivered very poor value for the money. One front desk associate was genuinely kind, welcoming, and did her best to help. Unfortunately, that was the highlight of our stay. The manager was dismissive, surprisingly rude, and showed very poor judgment when it came to resolving concerns. Rather than listening and finding solutions, we felt brushed aside. The rooms have extremely thin walls. We could clearly hear normal conversations from neighboring rooms, even though no one was being unusually loud. It made it very difficult to relax or get a good night’s sleep. Basic housekeeping was also disappointing. Soap dispensers were left empty and were not refilled, which reflects a lack of attention to even the simplest guest comforts. Luxury hospitality is about more than attractive marketing—it is about service, comfort, attention to detail, and making guests feel valued. Sadly, this property fell short on all of those fronts. There are far better options in the area that offer a much better experience for the price. I would not stay here again, and I cannot recommend it.

Nathalie · US · 2026-07-09

Lovely stay but way over priced for services

8.0

Lovely design and decoration of period buildings and port cabins. I liked the cafe area and bar and the mattresses were very comfortable.

− The amenities were very basic and the hotel charges were exuberant. Did not match the price.

Reem · AE · 2026-06-27

Very relaxing!

9.0

Very Nice.

Charies J · US · 2026-06-24

Guest review

10.0

Parking was free and really easy. Great proximity to the main street of town—you can easily walk, but it's not too close where it gets loud at night. The front staff and cleaning team were all lovely and super helpful. We loved the coffee bar in the mornings.

Katherine · 2025-10-01

Guest review

8.0

staff seemed tired and fed up of people staying!

andrew · 2025-09-25

Guest review

10.0

Quaint hotel in town. It’s perfect!

Ivonne · 2025-09-24

Good to know

Our seasonal outdoor swimming pool is open from Memorial Day and closes on the Sunday of Columbus Day Weekend *Weather permitting.Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.

A deposit may be required at the property.

›Parking

Free private parking is possible on site (reservation is not needed).

›Internet

WiFi is available in all areas and is free of charge.

›Pets

Pets are not allowed.

›Children and extra bed policy

Children of any age are allowed.

Children up to and including 1 year old stay for US$25 per person per night when using an available cot.

Children up to and including 5 years old stay for free when using an existing bed.

Children up to and including 11 years old stay for free when using an available extra bed.

People 12 years old and over stay for US$25 per person per night when using an available extra bed.

Any type of extra bed or child's cot/crib is upon request and needs to be confirmed by management.

Supplements are not calculated automatically in the total costs and will have to be paid for separately during your stay.