Destination
Hotels in Shelter Island
5 properties
Compare 5 hotels in Shelter Island on Sleepfare.
The "from" prices are indicative and refreshed regularly; the exact price for your dates is confirmed live the moment you open a hotel. Everything happens on Sleepfare itself, with no handoff to a third-party site.
9.1The Pridwin Hotel
★★★★ · 147 reviews
See prices
live at search
9.2Sunset Beach Hotel
★★ · 11 reviews
See prices
live at search
5.6Rams Head Inn
★★ · 5 reviews
See prices
live at search
6Shelter Island Retreat w/ Outdoor Pool!
★★★
See prices
live at search
4Sandpoint by Rove Travel Modern 5BR w Pool
★★
See prices
live at search
Good to know
- How current are the prices for Shelter Island?
- The "from" prices here are refreshed regularly for a sample two-night stay; the exact price for your dates is confirmed live when you open a hotel.
- Can I book directly on Sleepfare?
- You can search and compare every hotel on Sleepfare now; on-site card payment is opening shortly. When it does, payment is processed by our booking partner Nuitée, never a redirect to a third-party checkout.